Instead of cutting out more shapes with the left over peanut butter and oatmeal dough, I rolled it into balls. Then I made a cross hatch fork mark on the dog cookies. This is the same way you would do for human peanut butter cookies.
Have you made this recipe? What was your experience? Did your dog gobble it up or take a polite sniff and walk away?
Share your dog's Taste Bud Feedback with other dog treat bakers.
Share photos of your dog, or your dog eating this homemade dog treat, or how the finished dog treat looks! :)
Click below to see what other dog treat bakers are saying...
Is there a way to preserve the treats for a longer counter-life in a sealed container of course?
I am anxious to make these for all the doggies in my family for their Xmas treats! Thank you -- I will have to find a flour that my germ.shep. can tolerate,...
Could you add dried cranberries to this peanut butter dog biscuit recipe?
My dog is waiting for mom to make these yummy treats!
Chef's Answer ~ Yes, I believe you could add dried cranberries to this recipe. If possible,...
Make your own oat flour
A few years back I was in charge of the recipe page for a small newspaper. One of my favorite recipes is still Oat Pancakes made by putting regular oats ...
Could you use quaker quick oats?
I have the quick oats with me but i don't want to go out and buy the rolled oats. Would this affect the recipe?
Chef's Answer ~ I believe that quick ...
This was extremely sticky even when I added water.
I found that this recipe was impossible to roll out. Needless to say, there was a huge mess. How do I solve this? Also, I would like to know how many this ...
Dog treats are a hit
I can't make enough of these to keep up with the demands of two German Shepherds. They know how to make their wishes known and what can I do but mix up ...
My sister and I loved this dog treat recpie!
My owners made this recipe for my birthday for me and my sister(Lady) and I love them! We got over 120 small size biscuits. Our owners cooked them for ...
Adding Sourdough to recipes
I make a sourdough starter with the flour the night before I'm going to make the dog treats and then add it to the recipe, adjusting the flour to get the ...
My doggies went crazy for this dog treat recipe!!!
These were so easy to make! The dough was a little sticky so I added some oat bran to thicken it up. Instead of rolling them out I shaped them into mini ...
My Terriers Love Them!
I made these treats for my rat terrier and jack/rat terrier. They LOVED them! The one thing I did slightly differently, though, was I made them the size ...
Made several batches of dog treats, now have tips to share
I make these treats for two large dogs, one pit bull and one wolf-like mix.
Since they are bigger dogs, I make the treats much thicker and much dryer ...
Cooking time is 40 min? Most other recipes call for 20 min
Just wanted to make sure I read instructions correctly.
Also, can you use parchment paper instead of greasing cooking sheets? I usually have 3 large ...
Thank You for the Dog Treat Recipes
I really appreciate your web site. I have made this recipe along with several others, including the tuna fish and the cheese biscuit. My dogs love the ...
Simple Upgrades to these Homemade Dog Treats
My dogs (a collie and doxie) love these things.
Playing around with it, we've upped the peanut butter to a half cup, add 1 Tbsp honey, 1 tsp vanilla,...
Peanut Butter/Oatmeal recipe - My dog's new favorite
Well, this is the easiest cookie recipe ever! I have made several batches of this, both with and without wheat flour (oat flour is my preferred alternative)...
Can I Use Bread Flour?
I want to make my dog this treat, but I only have bread flour, will the recipe still work if I don't have whole wheat flour?
Chef's Answer ~ Bread ...
My dogs absolutely loved these
I made some of these for my dogs and also made up some little baggies for coworkers who i know have dogs. The response was amazing - everyone came back ...
Great Recipe!
Thanks very much my dog loved them. They are great, quick, and easy but did find them a bit crumbly. No worries my dog just licked it up!
My dog loves the peanut butter with oatmeal dog treat recipe!
This is a great and easy recipe! My dog loves peanut butter, so I felt sure she would like the treats I made, but I was so surprised at her reaction. I ...
Cookie Lovin'
My dogs loved them! They just kept looking at me like I was a goddess or something. They ate the cookies like there was no tomorrow.
wheat flour or whole wheat flour?
Is there a difference and must we use "whole" as opposed to just "wheat" flour? Does it make a difference in the quality of the recipe? I can't seem to ...
What is the subtitution for the rolled oats in this recipe?
I have ingredient but the rolled oats so what is another substitution for it.
Chef's Answer ~ I'm sorry, but there isn't a substitution for it that ...
Dog Treat Shelf Life
Hi. I am concerned about the shelf life of dog biscuits and treats. Can you instruct me as to what ingredients or baking methods that would provide a ...
How the heck do you roll this out??
This stuff is SOOOOOO sticky it is impossible to roll out. Is there better way to do this?? Please help!
Chef's Answer ~ You're right, the dough ...
Peanut Butter Dog Treats are Easy
These snacks were without a doubt the simplest
to make, and my two Yorkies are still begging for more.
I will be making these treats as gifts for my ...
How long will the peanut butter dog biscuits stay fresh, in a closed container?
Can't wait to try!
Chef's Answer ~ These will last a good 2 weeks in a air tight container, providing they are baked crispy (or hard). It's a good ...
How many does this recipe yield?
just wondering how many treats this recipe makes..thank you
Chef's Answer ~ It depends on what shape you cut out as to how many dog cookies you'll ...
Can I Add Carob Chips?
Has anyone added carob chips to this recipe?
Thanks
Chef's Answer ~ This would be a great recipe to add carob chips to! Mix them in when you ...